Hey Reader,
I've been sitting with a lot of questions lately.
After years of studying and practicing EMDR, Internal Family Systems (IFS), and Somatic Experiencing (SE), I sometimes find myself sitting with a client thinking, I could tell you what each of these models would say to do right now. But which one is right?
Should I be more direct? Less direct? Is this the right intervention? What is the most helpful structure? How much should research determine my approach, and how much should I trust my clinical experience, intuition, and the lived reality of the person sitting across from me?
And you know what? most of the time —
I don't actually know the answer.
And it's not just in the therapy room.
My wonderful three-nager whines, yells, and sometimes hits when he doesn't get what he wants. I know what I don't want to do. But what is the most helpful, supportive, non-damaging way to respond? What can I confidently say is the best answer?
I have no idea.
Another AI article pops into my inbox, simultaneously warning about the end of the world and celebrating incredible breakthroughs. Am I behind? Am I going to lose my job? Should I change careers and get a degree in AI? Am I an idiot if I don't jump on the train? How afraid should I be? Can I ignore it for now?
Yeah – I’m not really sure.
A client sits across from me, overwhelmed by self-hatred and wanting to die. Countless seasoned professionals have been hired and fired by this client before—none of them making a measurable difference. What is the right way through? What will actually work? I have some stuff to try but ultimately,
I don't know.
The systems of government and checks and balances I was raised to believe would protect us are increasingly unable to prevent, and now perpetrate, horrendous abuses of power. How do I protect myself, my family, and my neighbors? What is mine to pick up, and what is okay to hide away from?
I really really don't know.
What happens next? What should I do? How does this end?
I.
Don't
Know.
And as a quick aside, not knowing the right answer and not having any responsibility to act are not the same thing. I can be accountable to my clients, my children, and my ethical obligations without possessing certainty about outcomes or right answers. The responsibility is real. The uncertainty is real. Both are real.
In the Soup
I've been thinking about what to call this place.
I've heard it called the soup. Liminal space. The caterpillar in the cocoon. The in-between. The now and not yet. Ultimately, it's the place where we don't have it yet.
The answer. The solution. The understanding. The healing. The clear path. The relief. The fullest completion. The resolution.
And if this experience were an easy thing to be with, then we could have an interesting discussion and all go back to our busy days. But what I see in my clients, my colleagues, and myself is that being in this unknown space is often a painful trigger.
Into the Abyss
Some part of me likes to hop in here and say, "Why?! Why do you freak out so much when you have to wait for a resolution you're not sure will come? Better suck it up, Buttercup, because this is life! Don't you know control is an illusion and there is probably no right answer anyway?!"
Maybe. And. The rest of me is hesitant to try to bypass the discomfort too quickly.
Because being in the soup isn't necessarily just a temporary blip of discomfort while we wait for an answer. Sometimes it reaches into the very foundations of how we understand ourselves and our safety in the world.
Why? Because I don't know what to do quickly leads to Am I doing something wrong? Can I trust myself? Is it my fault? and What if I can't figure this out? What if I’m a fraud? What if I fail?
And from there, it’s only a step over into the lovely pits of shame (I am bad. Unworthy. Not enough.) and powerlessness (I am helpless. I have no control. I am fundamentally unsafe.).
These aren't just uncomfortable feelings. Shame and powerlessness are the most intolerable emotional experiences we can have. When these experiences become overwhelming, our nervous systems can respond as though our very survival is threatened…. Because it is.
Fight. Flight. Freeze. Shutdown. Dissociate.
Anger feels better than fear. Control feels better than helplessness. Frantically searching for answers feels better than sitting in the unknown. Anything to avoid feeling the full weight of I am powerless or There is something fundamentally wrong with me.
And when we cannot fight, escape, or find safety, sometimes our system is forced into another level of shut down.
I cannot exist.
There's a reason prolonged experiences of helplessness, terror, and overwhelming shame can be profoundly traumatic. Our minds and bodies adopt some pretty creative, if extreme, ways to be able to survive those experiences.
Experiences of being in the messy middle are not simply a failure to tolerate uncertainty. They can serve as a lightning rod to feelings of shame and powerlessness.
Sometimes it's an abyss.
So how do we make it through?
Having wrestled with my own experiences of... whatever the heck we're calling this... and walked alongside others navigating their own abyss (abysses?), I've found that people often land on a few key resources to get through.
And even through feels a little misleading. As though we eventually arrive at some final place where we've figured everything out. I'm not sure we ever fully get beyond the unknown this side of death. And maybe not even then.
Regardless, you'll probably recognize a variety of philosophies, spiritual traditions, and therapeutic approaches here.
- Identify what you CAN control. And then focus your effort on controlling what you can control. My "handle shit" and "don't tell me I can't" parts love this one. They love to remind me that we are rarely as powerless as we feel.
- Accept what you cannot change. That acceptance brings with it a level of peace in not having to try to control the uncontrollable. Not because whatever is happening is okay, but because it's happening.
- Find or create meaning in the pain or discomfort. Learning from it, redeeming it, or turning suffering into a cause, a mission, or a determination to protect others. We are meaning-making and meaning-craving beings. When we find some kind of meaning or significance to the pain, we experience it as—if not worth it—at least significant when it can be used for good.
- Find security in something or someone more powerful than yourself. The universe. God. Life. Consciousness. A community or society with more power than you alone possess. Like every baby knows, a capable, loving, powerful someone is the most soothing option when we have met our own limits.
- Make friends with the discomfort of being in the soup. Not knowing how things will turn out is uncomfortable, but it doesn't have to be debilitating. Change your relationship with uncertainty rather than needing to conquer it.
- And some people find their answer with presence. Not fixing. Not explaining. Not finding meaning. Just being here, in what is, perhaps alongside someone else who is willing to be here too.
Which is right? Which is most helpful? Which do I need? Which one(s) will actually make a difference for the person in front of me, if at all?
I truthfully do not know.
So why am I sharing all this?
Ha.
I guess it feels important? Maybe? I'm seeing it freaking everywhere and it feels like it matters?
(Receiving more side-eye from my parts. Is this newsletter just a navel-gazing ramble of self-gratification? Hope not. smh)
I've spent all this time exploring the experience of not knowing, and now here I am, wanting to give you a tidy bow. Some final conclusion about what I believe. What I know. What I've learned. Something to ease the intolerable system freak-out I experience when I'm dropped unceremoniously into my own pit of powerlessness and unknowing.
And perhaps that desire for a conclusion is just another attempt to escape the very thing I've been writing about, right or wrong.
I suppose even without a tidy conclusion, if I had one thing I wanted to say, it would be:
If you doubt yourself, want to escape the world around you, and feel despair and helplessness because of whatever soup you are experiencing right now—know that you are normal. Unknown and unsettled circumstances often shake us, not just externally, but can easily reach our very sense of self and ability to exist in the world. If you are in this spot (or have been in the past, or will be again soon), know that you make sense.
And I'm in the soup too.
And that's where I am, for now.
Warmly,
Alli